FRANKFORT, Ky. — Editor's note: The above video is when a Kentucky Senate committee approved the proposal.
More Kentucky teenagers charged with gun-related felony offenses would be transferred to adult courts to face trial under legislation passed by the state Senate on Wednesday.
The measure cleared the Senate on a 25-9 vote to advance to the House. Senate Bill 20 is part of a broader push in the GOP-dominated legislature to toughen penalties for a range of crimes.
Under the bill, youths would be transferred to circuit court for trial as adults when charged with serious felony offenses and if they used a gun when allegedly committing the crime. It would apply to youths 15 years old and up and for offenses that include robbery or assault.
Republican Sen. Matthew Deneen, the bill's lead sponsor, said it would ensure that “the time fits the crime” for gun-related offenses committed by teens.
“We owe the victims of these gun-related felonies justice, by holding these perpetrators accountable," Deneen said. "Gun-related crimes are jeopardizing our right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.”
The measure would roll back a criminal-justice policy enacted three years ago in Kentucky.
At that time, lawmakers ended the automatic transfer of youths from juvenile court to circuit court in certain cases. Judges now have to hold a hearing to determine whether a transfer is appropriate based on evidence. Once in circuit court, teens can face the same penalties as adults, including prison. Under the new bill, teens convicted in circuit court would be held in a facility for juveniles until turning 18.
Republican Sen. Whitney Westerfield, who opposed the new bill, said there's nothing to indicate that judges are systematically refusing to send such cases involving violent offenses to circuit courts.
“There is not one whit of evidence that that’s happening, because it’s not happening,” he said.
Westerfield has been at the forefront of juvenile justice reforms in recent years.
He said the bill would remove a judge’s discretion in deciding which court should hear a case. Various factors are considered, including the youth’s prior record, the likelihood of rehabilitation, whether the child has a serious intellectual disability or there was evidence of gang participation.
The bill was amended to allow prosecutors to return such cases to juvenile court. Westerfield responded that it's “exceedingly rare” for cases to return to juvenile court once they're transferred to circuit court.
Opponents also said the focus should be on the root causes of juvenile crime — such as poverty and recruitment into gangs — as well as intervention and education efforts that can drive down youth crime.
Republican Sen. John Schickel responded that the measure is a justifiable response to a groundswell of public frustration over the state's juvenile justice laws.
“The public has lost faith that justice is being served with these serious juvenile crimes,” he said.
Make it easy to keep up-to-date with more stories like this. Download the WHAS11 News app now. For Apple or Android users.
Have a news tip? Email assign@whas11.com, visit our Facebook page or Twitter feed.